Skip to main content
Financial ServicesWealth Management✓ Verified
Venice, Sarasota County
Last verified: Wednesday, October 21, 2026
Caldwell Trust Company
About This Organization

Caldwell Trust Company is an independent, Florida-chartered fiduciary trust company and wealth management institution headquartered on Center Road in Venice, with a Downtown Sarasota office on South Orange Avenue in Sarasota County, Florida. Co-founded in 1993 by Chairman, President, and Chief Executive Officer R. G. ("Kelly") Caldwell Jr. and his late father Roland G. Caldwell, and staffed by credentialed trust and investment officers including Executive Vice President and Senior Trust Officer Wendy Fishman, CTFA, Vice President and Senior Portfolio Manager Gail Neujahr, CFA, and Trust Officer Molly Setsma, CFP®, MBA, the company serves retirees and families across Venice, Sarasota, Osprey, and North Port with corporate trustee services, estate settlement, and fiduciary retirement portfolio management.

Official Verification Sources: Caldwell Trust Company Official Website; Caldwell Trust Company Leadership & Officers Directory

Verified State & Regulatory Credentials
Florida-Chartered Fiduciary Trust Company: FL OFR Charter (Est. 1993)Status: Active Chartered Trust Institution

Issuer: Florida Office of Financial Regulation (Division of Financial Institutions)

Notes: Independent, state-chartered non-depository trust company regulated by the Florida Office of Financial Regulation since 1993; Corporate Headquarters at 1400 Center Rd, Venice, FL 34292 and Sarasota Office at 27 S Orange Ave, Sarasota, FL 34236.

CTFA, CFA® & CFP® Trust & Investment Officers: Venice & Sarasota Fiduciary TeamStatus: Active CTFA, CFA® & CFP® Professionals

Issuer: American Bankers Association / CFA Institute / CFP Board

Notes: Led by Chairman, President & CEO R. G. ('Kelly') Caldwell Jr. alongside Executive VP & Senior Trust Officer Wendy Fishman, CTFA, VP & Senior Portfolio Manager Gail Neujahr, CFA, and Trust Officer Molly Setsma, CFP®, MBA.

Services Offered
Florida-Chartered Corporate Trustee, Co-Trustee & Successor Trustee Services
CFA® & CFP® Fiduciary Retirement Portfolio & Investment Management
Certified Trust and Financial Advisor (CTFA) Estate & Trust Administration
IRA Rollover, Rollover Trust & Required Minimum Distribution Management
Senior Bill-Pay, Incapacity Financial Stewardship & Care Coordination
Philanthropic Foundation, Charitable Remainder Trust & Legacy Planning
Frequently Asked Questions

Factual details and direct answers about Caldwell Trust Company's services, licensing, and credentials.

What makes Caldwell Trust Company in Venice and Sarasota unique for retirees?

Founded in Venice in 1993, Caldwell Trust Company is an independent, Florida-chartered trust company regulated by the Florida Office of Financial Regulation that can legally serve as corporate trustee, successor trustee, or personal representative alongside managing retirement and investment portfolios.

What professional credentials do the officers at Caldwell Trust Company hold?

Led by Chairman, President, and CEO R. G. ('Kelly') Caldwell Jr., the team includes Certified Trust and Financial Advisor (CTFA) Executive VP Wendy Fishman, Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) Senior Portfolio Manager Gail Neujahr, and Certified Financial Planner™ (CFP®) Trust Officer Molly Setsma, MBA.

Where are Caldwell Trust Company's offices located in Sarasota County?

The corporate headquarters is located at 1400 Center Road, Venice, Florida 34292, and its Downtown Sarasota office is located at 27 South Orange Avenue, Sarasota, Florida 34236.

Related Senior Support Services in Venice, Sarasota County

Connect with complementary legal, financial, and residential providers serving seniors in Venice and Sarasota County.

Contact Information
Address
1400 Center Rd
Hours
Mon-Fri 8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Take Action

Disclaimer: This directory listing is for informational purposes only. Florida Senior Support does not endorse or guarantee the quality of services. Please verify information and services directly with the organization.